AmazingBuyz is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
The best coffee roasters in Chicago and the Midwest include three standout Chicago roasters plus small-batch shops in Grand Rapids, St. Louis, Topeka, Indianapolis and Cleveland. Each sells whole-bean coffee online, so you can drink like a local without the drive. We compared roaster details, expert reviews and owner feedback, and we name one signature coffee to start with from each.
Part of our Coffee Buying Guides.
Our top picks at a glance
- Best overall Chicago roaster: Metric Coffee (Chicago)
- Best espresso blend: Dark Matter Coffee (Chicago)
- Best Chicago house blend: Passion House Coffee Roasters (Chicago)
- Best Michigan roaster: Madcap Coffee (Grand Rapids)
- Best for bright, fruity filter coffee: Blueprint Coffee (St. Louis)
- Best award-winning veteran: PT’s Coffee Roasting Co. (Topeka, Kansas)
- Best value: Tinker Coffee Co. (Indianapolis)
- Best Ohio roaster: Rising Star Coffee Roasters (Cleveland)
| Roaster | City | Known for | Signature coffee | Ships nationwide | Price tier | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Metric Coffee | Chicago, IL | Antique Probat roasters and published green-coffee prices | En Masse | Yes (free US shipping over $75) | $$ | See price · Visit |
| Dark Matter Coffee | Chicago, IL | Imbibe’s 2020 Coffee Bar of the Year; art and music collabs | Unicorn Blood espresso blend | Yes (US and international) | $$ | See price · Visit |
| Passion House Coffee Roasters | Chicago, IL | Ambient, Mainstream and Experimental coffee lines | Chicago House Blend | Yes (advertises worldwide shipping) | $$ | See price · Visit |
| Madcap Coffee | Grand Rapids, MI | Grand Rapids specialty pioneer since 2008 | Bolt house blend | Online store (check at checkout) | $$ | See price · Visit |
| Blueprint Coffee | St. Louis, MO | Gives $1 per pound of Tektōn to local groups | Tektōn filter blend | Online store (check at checkout) | $$ | See price · Visit |
| PT’s Coffee Roasting Co. | Topeka, KS | Roast Magazine’s 2009 Macro Roaster of the Year | Flying Monkey Espresso | Yes (free over $50) | $ | Visit |
| Tinker Coffee Co. | Indianapolis, IN | Vintage Probat roasting and a Nicaragua education partnership | Conduit Blend | Online store (free over $40) | $ | Visit |
| Rising Star Coffee Roasters | Cleveland, OH | Employee-owned since 2020; seven Cleveland-area cafés | Koke (Ethiopia) | Ships via USPS Priority | $$ | Visit |
Price tiers are per standard retail bag (roughly 10–12 oz): $ under $18, $$ $18–25, $$$ over $25. Prices change often, so check the current listing. Metric, PT’s and Dark Matter state their US shipping outright; the others run online stores with shipping calculated at checkout, so confirm your address before you order. Some of these roasters also have Amazon listings, but buying direct is the surest way to get a recent roast date.
1. Metric Coffee — Best overall Chicago roaster
Xavier Alexander and Darko Arandjelovic founded Metric in 2013. Alexander had previously roasted and worked in quality control at Intelligentsia, and that background shows in how carefully Metric runs its roastery. It roasts on two antique Probat machines, a UG15 and a P25, and buys coffee directly from producers, paying premiums and publishing what it pays as part of what it calls radical transparency. The company is also working toward B Corp certification.
Start with En Masse, which Metric calls its medium-roasted flagship and describes simply as sweet and complex. It’s a dependable everyday coffee for drip, pour-over or a mild espresso. Metric sells subscriptions, including a Bottomless plan, and ships free within the US on orders over $75.
Visit if you’re in town: the flagship café is at 2021 W Fulton St in Chicago’s West Loop area, and Milli by Metric pours at 3110 N Kedzie Ave.
Why we picked it: Experienced roasters, transparent sourcing and clear nationwide shipping.
Keep in mind: The free-shipping threshold is high, and the roaster’s own page gives little tasting detail for En Masse.
What owners say: We found few published customer reviews, so the roasters’ track record and sourcing are the best quality signals here.
2. Dark Matter Coffee — Best espresso blend
Dark Matter grew out of Jesse Diaz’s roasting for Star Lounge in Ukrainian Village, which he began in 2008. It has since become one of Chicago’s most recognizable coffee brands, with eight Chicago-area cafés and one in New York. Imbibe named it Coffee Bar of the Year in 2020, and it’s known for loud packaging and collaborations with artists and musicians, including a Marky Ramone roast called Bowery Beat.
Unicorn Blood is the coffee to try. It’s an espresso blend that Dark Matter describes as cherry, praline and semi-sweet chocolate, and it sells in 12 oz bags. It also works well in a moka pot or a strong drip. Dark Matter ships within the US and internationally, and subscribers can save up to 15%.
Visit if you’re in town: Osmium Coffee Bar at 1117 W Belmont Ave in Lakeview is one of the brand’s best-known cafés.
Why we picked it: A national award, a big personality and a flagship espresso blend that’s easy to find.
Keep in mind: The roaster’s page doesn’t state a roast level for Unicorn Blood, and there’s no free-shipping threshold listed.
What owners say: Public reviews are thin; the Imbibe award and the brand’s loyal Chicago following are the strongest signals.
3. Passion House Coffee Roasters — Best Chicago house blend
Joshua Millman founded Passion House in 2011 and organizes its coffees into three lines: Ambient for year-round blends, Mainstream for seasonal single origins and Experimental for limited lots. The roaster says it keeps long-running relationships with its growers. It closed its Logan Square café in January 2024 but kept roasting, and it now serves coffee at other Chicago spots.
The Chicago House Blend is the natural first bag. Passion House lists notes of milk chocolate, almond and lemon zest, and the roast sits at medium to dark, which makes it a forgiving choice for drip machines and milk drinks. It comes in 12 oz bags or a 5 lb bag for heavy drinkers or offices. Subscriptions are offered, and a banner on the site advertises worldwide shipping.
Visit if you’re in town: try the Goose Island café at 1200 North Branch, or stop by the Garfield Park roastery at 328 N Albany Ave.
Why we picked it: A clear, well-organized lineup and a crowd-pleasing house blend named for its hometown.
Keep in mind: No free-shipping threshold is listed, and the Logan Square café is gone.
What owners say: We found few public reviews, so begin with a single bag before subscribing.
4. Madcap Coffee — Best Michigan roaster
Madcap opened its first café on Monroe Center in downtown Grand Rapids in 2008 and originally roasted in that building’s basement. It has since grown into one of Michigan’s best-known specialty roasters, and its coffees have earned critical praise, including a 91-point Coffee Review score for its Lake Effect blend.
Bolt, the house blend, is where to start. Madcap describes it as deep, syrupy and chocolatey, with low acidity and caramelized-sugar sweetness, and retailers sell it as a medium roast in 10 oz bags. If you like it, Madcap offers both Single Origin and Blends subscriptions. Shipping is calculated at checkout.
Visit if you’re in town: the original Monroe Center café at 98 Monroe Center NW is still pouring in downtown Grand Rapids.
Why we picked it: A pioneering Michigan roaster with a smooth, approachable house blend and flexible subscriptions.
Keep in mind: The website doesn’t spell out its shipping coverage or a free-shipping threshold.
What owners say: Published customer reviews are scarce, so lean on the roaster’s tasting notes and critical scores.
5. Blueprint Coffee — Best for bright, fruity filter coffee
Six partners opened Blueprint’s Delmar café and roastery in St. Louis in 2013. The company has a strong community bent: $1 from every pound of its Tektōn blend goes to a St. Louis grassroots organization that changes each quarter, and it runs coffee education classes for the public.
Tektōn is the signature. Blueprint calls it bright and fruity, with notes of brown sugar, citrus, florals, stone fruit and chocolate, and it’s built for filter brewing such as pour-over and drip. It comes in 10 oz, 2 lb and 5 lb sizes. If you prefer a darker cup, Blueprint’s Timespan is the alternative. Subscriptions run on a four-week schedule.
Visit if you’re in town: the Delmar Coffee Bar at 6225 Delmar Blvd sits in the Delmar Loop near Washington University.
Why we picked it: A lively, light-leaning filter blend and a give-back program built into every bag.
Keep in mind: Tektōn’s 10 oz bag sits at the top of the $$ tier, so compare by weight.
What owners say: We found few published reviews; the roaster’s tasting notes are your best guide.
6. PT’s Coffee Roasting Co. — Best award-winning veteran
Fred Polzin and Jeff Taylor opened PT’s in Topeka in 1993 and started roasting in 1997. Their Direct Trade program, launched in 2005, now accounts for nearly 80% of the coffee they buy, and Roast Magazine named PT’s its 2009 Macro Roaster of the Year. One of its coffees earned a 97-point Coffee Review score, and in 2017 PT’s bought San Diego’s Bird Rock Coffee Roasters.
Try Flying Monkey Espresso, a medium roast PT’s describes as chocolate, honey and graham cracker. It’s sweet enough for straight shots and sturdy enough for lattes. PT’s roasts to order and ships the same day, with most US addresses receiving coffee in about two business days, and domestic coffee orders over $50 ship free. Subscribe + Save takes 10% off.
Visit if you’re in town: PT’s runs a café in Topeka’s Wheatfield Village at 2811 SW Fairlawn Rd and another in Kansas City’s Crossroads at 310 Southwest Blvd.
Why we picked it: Three decades of roasting, a national award and some of the clearest shipping terms in this guide.
Keep in mind: The 10 oz bag is smaller than a standard pound, so check the price per ounce.
What owners say: Few public reviews turned up, but its long direct-trade record and roast-to-order shipping stand out.
7. Tinker Coffee Co. — Best value
Brothers-in-law Stephen Hall and Jeff Johnson started roasting as Tinker in Indianapolis in 2014. Indianapolis Monthly notes that they roast on a vintage Probat fitted with bean-temperature probes, and the company partners with Project Alianza to support education in Nicaraguan coffee communities.
The Conduit Blend is Tinker’s best-selling medium roast, which it describes as vibrant and balanced with a clean finish and a touch of fruit. It’s one of the more affordable bags in this guide and works in nearly any brewer. Tinker offers a monthly subscription, and orders over $40 ship free. Conduit sometimes shows a restock notice, so check stock before ordering.
Visit if you’re in town: The Firehouse at 5555 N Illinois St and the Market Street café at 380 E Market St are both in Indianapolis.
Why we picked it: A lower price tier, a low free-shipping threshold and an easygoing medium roast.
Keep in mind: The website doesn’t explicitly state nationwide shipping coverage.
What owners say: We found few published reviews, so start with one bag of Conduit.
8. Rising Star Coffee Roasters — Best Ohio roaster
Kim Jenkins founded Rising Star in Cleveland in 2012 with one roaster and one café. In 2020, three employees and an investor bought the company, and it has grown to seven Cleveland-area locations. Its stated philosophy is simple: buy very good coffee and pay farmers and producers enough to live on.
Koke, a honey-processed Yirgacheffe from Ethiopia, is one of its top sellers. Rising Star lists notes of mixed berry, lavender and lemon drop, so expect a bright, floral cup that shines in pour-over. Orders ship by USPS Priority, typically the next business day, and subscriptions in 1 or 2 lb sizes ship within 48 hours of roasting.
Visit if you’re in town: the Roastery at 3617 Walton Ave and the Hingetown café inside the Ohio City Firehouse at 1455 W 29th St are both worth a stop.
Why we picked it: Ohio’s standout pick, with fast shipping and fresh-roasted subscriptions.
Keep in mind: The site doesn’t list bag size, shipping cost or roast level for Koke.
What owners say: Public reviews are scarce; try Koke if you like fruity, floral coffee.
How to choose a Chicago or Midwest coffee roaster
Chicago has an outsized place in American specialty coffee. Intelligentsia, founded there in 1995 by Doug Zell and Emily Mange, became a major name in third-wave coffee before Peet’s bought a majority stake in 2015, and its alumni helped seed newer roasters like Metric. Elsewhere in the region, PT’s won Roast Magazine’s Macro Roaster of the Year back in 2009 and Imbibe named Dark Matter its 2020 Coffee Bar of the Year. With that much talent, these checks help you pick the right bag.
Look for a roast date
Coffee starts losing freshness soon after roasting. Roasters such as PT’s and Rising Star roast to order and ship within a day or two, so you get beans at their best. Look for the roast date on the bag and aim to finish whole beans within a few weeks of it.
Match the roast to how you brew
Light, fruity coffees like Blueprint’s Tektōn or Rising Star’s Koke shine in pour-over and drip. Medium roasts such as Metric’s En Masse, Madcap’s Bolt and Tinker’s Conduit are the safest all-rounders. Espresso blends like Dark Matter’s Unicorn Blood and PT’s Flying Monkey are built for shots and milk drinks.
Read the origin and process
Washed coffees tend to taste clean and bright, natural (dry-processed) coffees taste fruitier and heavier, and honey-processed coffees like Koke fall in between. Single origins show off one farm or region, while blends are designed to taste the same from bag to bag.
Grind fresh and grind right
Buy whole beans and grind just before brewing: fine for espresso, medium for drip and pour-over, and coarse for French press and cold brew. A burr grinder makes the biggest difference; see our coffee grinder guide.
Store beans properly
The National Coffee Association recommends an airtight, opaque container kept somewhere cool and dark, and buying one to two weeks’ worth at a time. If you buy a 2 or 5 lb bag, freeze the extra in a truly airtight container and thaw only what you need.
Compare by weight and check shipping
Bag sizes vary from about 10 oz to 12 oz, so compare price per ounce. Free-shipping thresholds range from $40 at Tinker to $75 at Metric, which changes the real cost of a single bag. Subscriptions usually add a discount and keep fresh coffee arriving on schedule.
Looking for a discount? Check our deals and coupon codes page.
FAQ
Why isn’t Intelligentsia on this list?
Intelligentsia is a Chicago original and an important third-wave roaster, but Peet’s has owned a majority stake since 2015. This guide focuses on independent roasters, so we picked Metric, Dark Matter and Passion House to represent Chicago.
Which Midwest roaster has the clearest nationwide shipping?
PT’s spells it out best: it roasts to order, ships the same day and says most US addresses get coffee in about two business days, with free domestic shipping over $50. Metric also offers free US shipping over $75.
Can I buy these coffees on Amazon?
Metric, Dark Matter, Passion House, Madcap and Blueprint have listings on Amazon. Ordering direct from the roaster is still the best way to be sure you get a fresh roast date.
Which roaster is best for espresso?
Dark Matter’s Unicorn Blood and PT’s Flying Monkey Espresso are both built for espresso. Metric’s En Masse and Madcap’s Bolt also work well as milder shots.
How long do whole beans stay fresh?
The National Coffee Association suggests roughly one to three weeks at room temperature in an airtight, opaque container. Freeze anything you won’t use in that window.
Related guides
- All coffee buying guides
- The best coffee roasters in the USA
- The best Texas and Southwest coffee roasters
- The best Colorado and Mountain West coffee roasters
- The best coffee subscriptions
Sources
Metric: Story · Barista Magazine: Metric Coffee · Metric: En Masse · Metric: Café · Daily Coffee News: Dark Matter · Imbibe: Coffee Bar of the Year · Dark Matter: Unicorn Blood · Dark Matter: Shipping · Passion House: Our story · Passion House: Chicago House · Madcap: Monroe Center · Madcap: Bolt · Coffee Review: Madcap Lake Effect · St. Louis Magazine: Blueprint · Blueprint: Tektōn · PT’s: Our story · Coffee Strategies: PT’s Roaster of the Year · PT’s: Flying Monkey · PT’s: Find us · Indy Chamber: Tinker · Indianapolis Monthly: Indy roasters · Tinker: Conduit · Rising Star: About · Rising Star: Koke · Rising Star: FAQ · Wikipedia: Intelligentsia · National Coffee Association: Storage
Owner feedback is summarized in our own words from public reviews. Photos courtesy of Unsplash.